2022-2023
- Mason Schwalbach-Kansas State University - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Tyler Castro-Eastern Illinois University - NCAA Division 1
- Aaron Rice-Utah Valley University - NCAA Division 1
- Evan Jackson-University of St. Thomas - NCAA Division 1
- Billy Howard-Ashland University - NCAA Division 2
- Tyler Upp-Belmont Abbey College - NCAA Division 2
- Evan Long-Belmont Abbey College - NCAA Division 2
- Jaden Hackbarth-Mount Mercy University - National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA)
- Josh Notriano-Mount Mercy University - NAIA
- Alex Janke-Indiana University-Kokomo - NAIA
- Michael Talesky-Indiana University-Kokomo - NAIA
2021-2022
- Grady Gorgen-Troy University - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Michael Moore-Southeast Missouri State - NCAA Division 1
- Owen Rice-UW-Milwaukee - NCAA Division 1
- Ben Peltz-Ashland University - NCAA Division 2
- Cody Horon-Northern State University - NCAA Division 2
- Danny Perdzock-Northern State University - NCAA Division 2
- Trevor Jaloszynski-McKendree University - NCAA Division 2
- Dymitri Kanellakis-Augustana College - NCAA Division 3
- Josh Belgrave-Wisconsin-Platteville - NCAA Division 3
- Luke Uhwat-Illinois Wesleyan - NCAA Division 3
- Josh Ralston-Illinois Wesleyan - NCAA Division 3
2020-2021
- Colin Kalinowski-Eastern Illinois University - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Sam Pederson-Northern Illinois University - NCAA Division 1
- AJ Henkle-University of Illinois-Chicago - NCAA Division 1
- Kyle Maurer-Purdue Fort-Wayne - NCAA Division 1
- Luke Ballweg-Augustana University (S.D.) - NCAA Division 2
- Jack Hines-Augustana University (S.D.) - NCAA Division 2
- Ben Belgrave-Missouri Science and Technology - NCAA Division 2
- Max Bruff-Wisconsin-Parkside - NCAA Division 2
- Nevin Wall-Winona State - NCAA Division 2
- Miller Wallace-Winona State - NCAA Division 2
- Hunter Olson-Missouri Western - NCAA Division 2
- Noah Wenger-Missouri Western - NCAA Division 2
- Hunter Rumachik-Missouri Western - NCAA Division 2
- Aidan Stark-Wisconsin-Parkside - NCAA Division 2
- Aiden Smith-Illinois Wesleyan - NCAA Division 3
- Ben Maxey-Illinois Wesleyan - NCAA Division 3
- Nick Finley-Benedictine-Mesa - National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA)
- Evan Geske-Benedictine-Mesa - NAIA
- Chance Larson-Benedictine-Mesa - NAIA
- Nick Vollmert-St. Ambrose University - NAIA
2019-2020
- Kyle Lang-Eastern Illinois University - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Danny Sperling-Southeast Missouri State University - NCAA Division 1
- Kory Olsen-Western Illinois University - NCAA Division 1
- Jackon Mandella-University of Charleston (WV) - NCAA Division 2
- Bryce Toussaint-University of Charleston (WV) - NCAA Division 2
- Kyle Bullock-Rollins College (FL) - NCAA Division 2
- Cory Busse-Limestone College (SC) - NCAA Division 2
- Joey Brown-Saint Ambrose University - National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA)
- Nolan Unger-Indiana University-South Bend - NAIA
2018-2019
- Jeff Heinrich-University of South Carolina - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Ryan Parquette-Campbell University - NCAA Division 1
- John Vanderploeg-Campbell University - NCAA Division 1
- Austin Domer-University of Akron - NCAA Division 1
- Jimmy Staab-SIU Carbondale - NCAA Division 1
- Kyle Back-SIU Carbondale - NCAA Division 1
- Zach Teegen-Lewis University - NCAA Division 2
- Travis Baily-Wayne State College - NCAA Division 2
- Justin Mercer-Ashland University - NCAA Division 2
- Bryce Brogni-Univ. of Wisconsin-Parkside - NCAA Division 2
- Michael Lehner-Univ. of Wisconsin-Parkside - NCAA Division 2
- Logan Rezash-Lindenwood University - NCAA Division 2
- Scott Nygren-Upper Iowa University - NCAA Division 2
- Kiley Brown-Upper Iowa University - NCAA Division 2
- Alex Saunders-Univ. of Wisconsin-Parkside - NCAA Division 2
- Ethan Weinandy-Wisconsin-Oshkosh - NCAA Division 3
- Jacob Slonim-Edgewood University - NCAA Division 3
- Jordan Van Dyke-Wisconsin-LaCrosse - NCAA Division 3
- Ryan McGorrian-Central Methodist University - National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA)
2017-2018
- Ryan Anderson-Northern Illinois University - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Austin Franczak-University of Illinois-Chicago - NCAA Division 1
- Alex Cimaroli-Wagner College - NCAA Division 1
- Jason Decicco-Eastern Illinois University - NCAA Division 1
- Cole Hansel-Chicago State University - NCAA Division 1
- Mark Wanner-Washburn University - NCAA Division 2
- Matthew Nagel-Southwest Baptist University - NCAA Division 2
- Tyler Stamer-Rockhurst University - NCAA Division 2
- Larkin Hanselmann-UW-Whitewater - NCAA Division 3
- Logan Streit-Rockford University - NCAA Division 3
- Tyler Bujanowski-UW-Whitewater - NCAA Division 3
- Jake Fiorito-Clarke University - National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA)
2016-2017
- Brett Stratinsky-Middle Tennessee State - National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1
- Wyatt Mascarella-St. Johns University - NCAA Division 1
- Peyton Schneider-Texas Southern University - NCAA Division 1
- Sam Hawley-Ashland University - NCAA Division 2
- Nick Vasic-SIU-Carbondale - NCAA Division 1
- Justin Blasinski-Illinois-Springfield - NCAA Division 2
- Nick Heidenthal-Chicago State University - NCAA Division 1
- Austin Butts-Transylvania University - NCAA Division 3
- Nick Porretto-Eastern Michigan University NCAA Division 1
- Tyler Jones-Eastern Illinois University - NCAA Division 1
- Alex Marro-South Dakota State University - NCAA Division 1
- Collin Chubb-UW-Platteville - NCAA Division 3
- Ben Cusac-Keiser University (FL) - National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA)
- Owen Oreskovich-Mount Mercy University - NAIA
- Jason Macalpine-Grand View University - NAIA
