2019-2020 Successful Scots
- Alyssa Iverson Lipscomb University DI
- Adelyn Ringel Judson University NAIA
2018-2019 Successful Scots
- McKaylie Krey Judson University NAIA
- Jasmine Glover Trinity Christian University NAIA
- Lacey Gardner University of St. Francis DII
2017-2018 Successful Scots
- Kaleigh Johnson Lindenwood University NAIA
2016-2017 Successful Scots
- Makenna Powell North Park University DIII
- Quixmia Washington Arizona Christian University NAIA
2015-2016 Successful Scots
- Carmisha Chavers Roosevelt University DII
- Becky Blando Cardinal Stritch University NAIA